The Next Generation of Visual Website Optimizer is launching in April 2014 See What's Coming

107% increase in sales shows that customers care more for authenticity than low prices

Posted in A/B Split Testing, Case Studies on June 7th, 2012

eCommerce websites that sell branded products need to ensure that customers know the products are original and not an imitation. If your customers are not sure about the originality, they’re never convinced about the quality of the product and any price will seem like too much. This problem is especially grave in the online world because unlike a physical store they don’t interact with a sales person face to face and moreover they cannot touch and feel the product online to determine the authenticity of the product. So stressing on originality and authenticity (especially for higher priced products) becomes quite important for eCommerce stores. One of our customers, High Position, an integrated digital marketing agency, was trying to understand what works best for their client, Express Watches. Express Watches is a UK based online retailer of Seiko watches and one major consumer anxiety was whether the watches were actually real or an imitation. HP-Group wanted to run a test that would clearly eliminate this anxiety.

What was A/B tested and why?

To ensure customers knew that Express Watches stocks original products, HP-Group replaced an image on the right hand side of the product that initially said “Never Beaten on Price” in the control.

Control – “Never Beaten on Price”

The variation said “Seiko Authorized Dealer Site” in strong blue, black and white.

Variation – “Seiko Authorized Seller Site”

The result was a 107% jump in conversion rate during the 30 day test, taking conversion rate from 1.81% to 3.76% overall and effectively doubling Express Watch’s business. Note that this badge of authenticity was not simply added as an extra, but in fact it replaced the badge in control that guaranteed low prices. This clearly shows that customers care more about the authenticity of a product than low prices.

Result: 107% increase in sales, effectively doubling Express Watch’s sales

The results were surprising for HP-Group, but reinforced that everything needs to be tested, specially so on consumer facing eCommerce websites. The client learnt that customers need to clearly know that the seller is authorized by the brand and carries only original products, a reinforcement of the fact that they won’t be ripped off. Since HP-Group uses Visual Website Optimizer, they said that

“Having used other CRO / UX testing services, Visual Website Optimizer is by far the best. It’s easy to use and setup the tests. The dashboard is great, easy to navigate and provides the detailed information you need. The ability to quickly share the results is great.”

To see more such case studies, visit our Case Study page. If you have done any such tests on your website, please do let us know via comments.

Siddharth Deswal

I do marketing at Visual Website Optimizer.

The Complete A/B Testing Guide

Know all that you need to get started:

  • What is A/B Testing?
  • Is it compatible with SEO?
  • How to start your first A/B test?
Show Me The Guide


June 8, 2012

We spotted similar trend when selling designer eyeglasses, handbags etc, where people are more interested in product authenticity, due to the fact there is so much counterfeit websites selling identically looking products.

June 8, 2012

Jan, how did you solve that problem? Did a similar “Authentic” badge work for you, or was there something else you did?

June 9, 2012

But now there is “Never beaten on Price” logo in this place again

June 9, 2012


And they’ve also included the “Seiko Authorized Dealer Site” right next to the logo. Given that they’re regularly testing and optimizing, it’s quite likely that they found this to be the best combination.

June 15, 2012

“This clearly shows that customers care more about the authenticity of a product than low prices.”

While the results are good, I’m worried that this isn’t a valid statement – the seiko version stands out a lot more with the blue border, so they’re more likely to see it. I’d suggest making another test where the price guarantee is in the same colors (or vice versa) and see if the results are the same.

I’d say that the visitors react better to option B than A, but not that it’s because of the message in option B.

June 18, 2012

hi all

looks interesting! is it possible to know how many visits the page received during the test?


June 18, 2012

Hi Guys, thanks for the feedback. Product authenticity is still a big online consumer anxiety – this was the original hypothesis of the test. I have since updated the test by combining the Authorised Seiko blue badge with a Free Next Day Delivery logo as this USP also performed well during the multivariant test.

I will share my findings.

(Shane, great point on the blue colour, although I don’t agree that the colour is the reason for this test’s success rather than the message – I will test it though of course)

June 30, 2012

Fantastic information.

So the choice of strong black and blue colouring, doesn’t appear as aesthetically pleasing as the rest of the site. Was this on purpose? And why black and blue?

thank you.

Leave a comment
Required - not published

× five = 40

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

I ♥ Split Testing Blog

Stay up to date

Recent Posts

Write for this blog!

We accept high quality articles related to A/B testing and online marketing. Send your proposals to